Similar to most low and middle income countries, the measurement of poverty in India is understood as an annual affair. Traditional policy discourse documents it as an annual headcount metric that is typically described as the proportion of all households facing an income shortfall within a year. Consequently, all national poverty rates and anti-poverty policies are constructed and implemented, respectively, based on this understanding of poverty. However, such poverty statistics do not adequately describe the deprivations experienced by households. This is because low-income households face uncertainties of insufficiency, instability, and illiquidity in a manner that cannot be quantified into statistical averages. Moreover, households have developed coping mechanisms to address these uncertainties by smoothing their consumption, but they do so imperfectly and unevenly across the income distribution. Therefore, a more nuanced and grounded understanding of poverty is a necessary step toward designing policies that respond to poverty as it is actually lived, rather than how it is conventionally measured.
In the study based on Merfeld and Morduch’s Poverty at Higher Frequency framework, we use the Consumer Pyramids Household Survey (CPHS) for January 2018 to December 2023, and find that (i) high-frequency poverty is roughly twice low-frequency poverty, and that households classified as poor in a given year experience nine out of twelve months in poverty; (ii) the ability to smooth consumption varies with socioeconomic status, as more educated households better absorb income shocks without adjusting expenditure, while less educated households pass a larger share of income fluctuations through to consumption; and (iii) households above the poverty line remain exposed to deprivation, with exposure diminishing gradually and non-linearly with distance from the line and not becoming negligible until a household spends at roughly twice the poverty line. Ultimately, the contribution of the high-frequency framework is not to produce a different aggregate statistic but to make the temporal structure of poverty explicit, showing when, where, and for whom poverty accrues within the year.
Read the full policy brief here
You can access the working paper here
